Historically Thinking
Historically Thinking
They Knew They Were Pilgrims
0:00
-53:43

They Knew They Were Pilgrims

John Turner on Plymouth Colony, myth, and the contest for American liberty

Originally published on May 6, 2020 (Episode 157)

Introduction

Most Americans think they know something about the Pilgrims, based on a dimly remembered high school textbook, or perhaps from a second-grade Thanksgiving pageant: that the men wore stovepipe hats with brass buckles, and carried blunderbusses; that they were the first settlers in America, had the first Thanksgiving, got on well with the Indians; that they were uniquely tolerant while others all around them were not; that they were the most important settlers of New England, or the most influential.

And just about all of these things are wrong.

With me to discuss the Pilgrims—their origins, beliefs, settlement, and their importance—is John Turner, author of the new book They Knew They Were Pilgrims: Plymouth Colony and the Contest for American Liberty, published by Yale University Press.


About the Guest

John G. Turner is Professor of Religious Studies at George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia. His books include The Mormon Jesus: The Place of Jesus Christ in Latter-Day Saint Thought, and the award-winning Brigham Young: Pioneer Prophet. His work focuses on American religious history, new religious movements, and the intersections of religion and politics.


For Further Investigation

Listen & Discuss

What stands out to you in this episode? Share your thoughts in the comments below — and consider forwarding this post to a friend who would enjoy the conversation.


🦃 Subscribe to Historically Thinking for more episodes and essays on American origins, religion, and how myths shape our history.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar